Bing Hodneland logo

Bestsellers

Books

List Bestselling Books

DVDs

List Bestselling DVDs

Google

Sheet Music Plus Featured Sale
In Association with Amazon.co.uk

All the information on this site is free. But if it is of value to you, I appreciate a tip.


Previous page:

Notes on "Getting Better"

Next page:
Previous page: Notes on "Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds" Next page: Notes on "Fixing A Hole"

This article is from Alan W. Pollack's groundbreaking series "Notes on the Beatles". Links in the orginal article is written in this colour: index to the series, while links I have added appears as standard links. Go here for more information on my site about the song

Notes on "Getting Better"

KEY C Major

METER 4/4

FORM Intro -> Verse -> Refrain -> 
   Verse -> Refrain -> Bridge ->  Verse -> Refrain -> Bridge -> Outro 

General Points of Interest

Style and Form

In accord with the compositional advisory re: balancing contrasts, it is most fitting for abstract "Lucy..." to be followed by the more representational "Getting Better" with its simple harmonic structure, steady beat, and mischievously clear message of hope.

The musical focus here is on the elaborately detailed arrangement and the conjuring of a particular Pop/Jazz/Rock aesthetic fusion that was a McCartney specialty; the latter characterized by long phrases on pedal points and the stylized instrumentation and recording.

The whole thing reminds me of "Got To Get You Into My Life;" not just for the rave-up, vamping mood and long phrases, but also for the slightly elusive form. I've chosen to parse it as though the first Refrain is "slightly lacking" and the other Refrains are followed by a bridge. You could just as easily parse it with the bridge as an extension of the Refrains, and labelling the first one as "extremely lacking." The point is that the usually clear formal dividing lines are blurry here, and not easily defined definitively.

Melody and Harmony

The home key of the song is clearly C Major, though it can be described as having its center of gravity leaning heavily toward the V chord, based on the large amount of air time given to G.

Both the tune and the chord choices are "pan diatonic;" a fancy way of saying that no notes appear anywhere in the song that are not native to the home key, and that they are all considered consonant amongst other.

Paul's improvisational bass line borders on the hyperactive and makes an accurate transcription of the detailed harmony very difficult. Indeed, recording of the bassline *this* prominently is reminiscent of "Paperback Writer" and might be categorized as one of the musical leitmotifs of the entire "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band" album; at least side 1.

Though I generally do not shy away from digging down to that level of detail, in this case I'm going to restrict my analysis to the bigger picture. I'd rather move on to looking at other songs than obsess on this one :-) Besides, any time you have a sustained note in the bass part, it doesn't really matter what chords you play above it, to the extent that the bass note itself creates a transcending "envelope" of its own that sustains your attention.

In this song, for example, while you can spend hours trying to decipher exactly which chords are played over the G pedal tone of the verse, I don't think you'd argue against the notion that the entire verse is "parsed" in your mind as an elaborate V chord.

Arrangement

Though the final mix is very thick in terms of layered dubs, the musical texture is curiously spare with the bassline, percussion, vocals, tamboura, and a repeated chiming of piano and guitar on the G octave predominating. Yes, there are other instruments on the backing track, but they are restricted to a low profile.

They must have had much fun working out the details of this arrangement. Even if they were making it up as they were going along, the end result shows great attention to detailed patterning. Let's trace it by department:

VOCALS

The Beatles were renowned for their antiphonal and block choral use of backing vocals which appear throughout their songbook with regularity if not equal frequency. Here, they go to town:

Intro

Chorus

Verse 1

This one contains the most complicated arrangement. In the first two lines, you have Paul solo with John/George antiphonally extending his comments in the same first person (as opposed to answering him in the third person.) For the next two lines, the backing vocals answer only with ahh/ohh phonemes (sounding very much like the chief Blue Meany), and on the final word, "rules," they echo Paul with "fools" (?) and throw in a final "wooh!" for good measure. And note how sharply all the backing parts are syncopated.

Refrain 1

Paul leads, but the backers join him with a parroting of the word "better" at a rhythmically strange location ("rhymes with station"), and continue on with a quip that belies the unmuddied sentiment expressed by the lead.

Verse 2

The delicious complexity of the first verse is traded off this time for what sounds like Paul accompanying himself in parallel thirds. On the one hand, I miss the effect of the first verse, but I guess it would lose more than it would gain by a repeat. Do think that one over, Dimm.

Refrain 2

Same as before.

Bridge 1

Chorus followed by a moment of staggered three-part counterpoint.

Verse 3

Same as before.

Refrain 3

Same as before.

Bridge 2

Same as before.

Outro

Same as in the bridges.

PERCUSSION:

Intro

Standard drum kit first enters in the second half.

Verse 1

Cymbal slashes on the syncopated half-beat before FOUR.

Refrain1

Drums playing four-in-the-bar.

Verse 2

Cymbals as in Verse 1, with hand claps on TWO.

Refrain 2

Four-in-the-bar.

Bridge 1

Four-in-the-bar.

Verse 3

Indian "tabla" drums appear, and the hand claps this time are on FOUR. Late in the section, the cymbals resume their erstwhile slashing on three-AND; dig the "ka-chunk" effect created by the cymbals and hand claps appearing one eighth note apart. Note here, too, the heavy overlay of buzzing tamboura.

Refrain 3

Four in the bar again, though the Indian drums hang in there.

Bridge 2

Four in the bar again, though the Indian drums hang in there.

Outro

Layering applied in reverse -- eventually only the Indian drums are left.

CHIMING G OCTAVE:

Intro

Yes.

Verse 1

No.

Refrain 1

Yes.

Verse 2

No.

Refrain 2

Yes.

Bridge 1

Yes.

Verse 3

No.

Refrain 3

Yes.

Bridge 2

Yes.

Outro

Yes.

In other words, this chiming is ubiquitous as long as you're not in one of the verses.

By the way ... once it was pointed out to me by the lyrical transcription found in Things We Said Today, I too noticed the muffled "four-five-six" counting in the intro, but I honestly don't know what to make of it. While it sounds much more genuine than the fake "Taxman" count in, it makes no sense in terms of the number of measures on the recording. Perhaps, this suggests that there is something at the very beginning of the master tape that has been edited out of the official mix.

Section-by-Section Walkthrough

Intro

The intro is just four prescient measures long. The first two consist of just the chiming sonority that will yet characterize the song, and the final two give us a foretaste of the choral refrain to come.

The implied harmony of this intro as a IV->I plagal cadence, with a gratuitous, jazzy 9th applied to the F chord, a result of the G octave that is sustained for all four measures:

 |F  |-  |C  |F  |
C:  IV     I   IV


Verse

The verse is eight measures and breaks into four short phrases of equal length. As I said up top, we could spend a lot of time transcribing the exact vertical sonorities one hears in these eight measures, but it's healthy, sometimes, for the Gestalt-grasping part of your mind to acknowledge that this entire verse is "experienced" as a V chord.

Shades of something out of John's "Rain," the final verse has an extra measure added between the two phrases; very strange.

Refrain

Paul's bassline does indeed make it difficult to precisely parse the chords of this section. This is my take on it, but I'll be the first to admit that the bassline does NOT necessarily support my root progression:

 ------------------------------- 2X ------------------------------
 |C  |d  |e  |F       (G) |
  I   ii   iii   IV  (V)

[Chord stream I-ii-iii-IV-V] Suffice it to say that the refrain is eight measures long and consists of an almost literal repeat of the same four-measure phrase that, no matter how you precisely parse the chords, is a harmonically simple phrase that helps establish the home key.

Bridge

The bridge is more of an extension of the Refrain that it is a section in its own right. It is ten measures long, and after its opening two measures of almost Beethoven-like cadence, it proceeds with two repeats of a four measure phrase that is very similar to the Refrain:

  ------------------------------ 2X -
 |F   G   F    G |F   G   F    G |C  |d  |
  IV  V   IV   V  IV  V   IV   V  I   ii  
         
 
 ---------------------------------
 |e  |F  |
  iii   IV

Outro

The outro is an unusual "recombinative" reprise of material heard earlier in both Bridge and Intro:

  ||chimes only with tabla ....
 |F   G   F    G |F   G   F    G |C  | | | |
  IV  V   IV   V  IV  V   IV   V  I      (implied V?)

The last chord sounded is I, but the repeat of the G octave into the fadeout implies an indefinite harmonic ending on V rather than I. This embiguity is nicely exploited by the intro to the next track; but more on that next time.

Some Final Thoughts

At risk of appearing to damn with faint praise, this song is by no means a "bad" one, but on its very own, it surely shines on less brightly than any of the three songs that precede it on the A side of "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band".

This is not necessarily a deficit, and this "shining less brightly" is not at all a matter of "can't win them all" as much as it is one of the need, in pacing a continuous album side, of wanting to be able to relax the tension between acccumulative peaks without allowing the pot to grow so cold that the overall continuity is lost.

As such a role player, "Getting Better" admirably fulfills its mission.

Regards, Alan
(awp@world.std.com)
---
"We're trying." 123195#109 ---

Copyright (c) 1995 by Alan W. Pollack

All Rights Reserved

This article may be reproduced, retransmitted, redistributed and otherwise propagated at will, provided that this notice remains intact and in place.

These articles were originally posted in the News Group rec.music.beatles. The content from this newsgroup is archived at http://www.recmusicbeatles.com/, and Alan W. Pollacks "Notes On" series can be found at http://www.recmusicbeatles.com/public/files/awp/awp.html

. I used to link to the versions published in Soundscapes before I decided to include them on my own site.

If you want to learn more about the musical side of song writing, chord progressions, harmony and theory through The Beatles songs (and/or The Beatles in particular), I recommend the following book:

Artist: Dominic Pedler

Arranged by The Beatles


More >>

The Songwriting Secrets of the Beatles


Book of the Month 2003-10
The Songwriting Secrets Of The Beatles is an essential addition to Beatles literature - a new and perceptive analysis of both the music and the lyrics.

More than thirty years after The Beatles split up, the music of Lennon, McCartney and Harrison lives on. What exactly were the magical ingredients of those legendary songs? why are they still so influential for today's bands? This groundbreaking book sets out to exlore The Beatles' songwriting techniques in a clear and readable style. It is aimed not only at musicians but anyone who has ever enjoyed the work of one of the most productive and successful songwriting partnerships of the 20th century. Author Dominic Pedler explains the chord sequences, melodies and harmonies that made up The Beatles' self penned songs and how they uncannily complemented the lyrical themes. He also assesses the contributions that rhythm, form and arrangement made to the Beatles unique sound. Throughout the book the printed music of the Beatles' songs appears alongside the text, illustrating the authors explanations. The Songwriting Secrets of The Beatles is an essential addition to Beatles literature - a new and perceptive analysis of the music itself itself as performed by what Paul McCartney still calls 'a really good, tight little band'.

Level: , 816 pages
RefNr: 0711981671
Order From:
MusicRoom
Amazon UK
Amazon US
Previous page: Previous page: Notes on "Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds"Next page: Notes on "Fixing A Hole" Next page:

Previous page: Next page:
Previous page: Notes on "Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds" Next page: Notes on "Fixing A Hole"